Is Morganite a Good Choice for an Engagement Ring in 2025?

You've found the person—and now comes the ring. But in a sea of diamonds and headlines about lab-grown sparkle, one gem still whispers quietly to a different kind of bride: Morganite.

Delicate, peachy, and endlessly romantic, morganite rings rose to popularity during the vintage revival of the 2010s. They became the darling of Pinterest boards and jewellers' windows alike, thanks to their warm tones and affordability. However, a decade later, the engagement ring landscape has undergone significant changes.

Fun fact: Recent industry trend summaries highlight the rising popularity and increased sales of both pink stones and lab-grown options. Morganite? It's still loved—but it's no longer the only option for brides looking to blush.

Yet that's not to say it's completely fallen out of favour. Many couples still choose Morganite for its romantic hues, sentimental value, and the way it pairs so effortlessly with rose gold. But is it the right fit for everyday wear? How does it compare to newer favourites in terms of durability, treatment, and resale value? And what should you know if you're considering engagement ring insurance for a softer stone?

Together, we'll unpack Morganite's true pros and cons—from its luminous charm to the practical realities of wear, care, and cover. Because whether you're head-over-heels for peachy gems or just doing your homework, clarity matters—on the finger and the facts.

What Is Morganite?

A gentle gem with bold roots

Morganite is a softly coloured pink-to-peach gemstone from the beryl family—the same mineral group as emerald and aquamarine. Though its hue may feel ethereal, its history is surprisingly bold: it was named in honour of financier and gem collector J.P. Morgan in the early 1900s, during a time when pink gems symbolised power, not passivity.

Today, most Morganite you'll find in engagement rings have been heat-treated to deepen its colour. This treatment is stable and permanent, but it's not always disclosed upfront. That's why transparency—both in sourcing and in documentation—is essential if you're planning to insure your ring later on.

In terms of sparkle, Morganite offers a soft, luminous glow rather than high brilliance. With a refractive index of 1.57–1.60, it reflects light differently from a diamond or sapphire. Think candlelight rather than spotlight—romantic and warm, but slightly more muted.

Expert insight: Morganite's appeal lies in its femininity and softness—but those same qualities mean it needs thoughtful setting and maintenance if it's going to be worn daily.

Why Morganite Was Once the 'It' Engagement Gem

A budget-friendly blush in the spotlight

In the mid-2010s, Morganite was everywhere. Its soft pink glow paired perfectly with rose gold—fuelled by the rise of vintage-inspired designs and the Pinterest era's aesthetics. For couples seeking something "romantic but affordable," it ticked all the boxes.

Between 2015 and 2022, jewellers leaned into the trend, offering morganite engagement rings at accessible prices—typically A$250 to $1,200, depending on size, colour depth, and setting. It was often marketed as a dreamy, affordable alternative to pink sapphires or natural pink diamonds, which could cost ten times more per carat.

And it wasn't just everyday buyers who took notice. Celebrities like Lauren Conrad helped boost the gem's profile—her round-cut Morganite ring, set in rose gold, sparked a wave of similar styles across Instagram and Etsy.

But in 2025, the story has shifted.

Morganite is quietly stepping out of the spotlight. While still loved by some, it's now overshadowed by lab-grown pink diamonds, Australian sapphires, and browner, earth-toned diamonds with stronger resale narratives and ethical sourcing credentials. These newer picks offer both sparkle and story—traits today's couples increasingly seek.

Looking for more info on coloured stones? Dive into our blog, Beyond Diamonds: The Allure of Coloured Gemstone Engagement Rings.

Pros of Choosing Morganite for an Engagement Ring

The appeal

Morganite might not dominate 2025 trend lists, but its charm hasn't faded entirely. For some couples, it still strikes the perfect balance between softness, symbolism, and budget-friendliness.

Romantic palette

From whisper-soft blush to deeper peach, Morganite offers a spectrum of pink tones that feel tender and timeless. The gentle colour is often linked to emotional healing, love, and compassion—making it especially meaningful for proposals.

Budget-friendly brilliance

Compared to pink diamonds or sapphires, Morganite offers a lower engagement ring cost—meaning larger carat sizes are accessible without stretching the budget. That makes it popular with those who want size and sparkle without financial compromise.

Gold's perfect match

Morganite pairs naturally with rose gold, which enhances its warmth, or yellow gold for vintage-inspired designs. This compatibility has made it a staple in halo, solitaire and cushion-cut settings alike.

Easy to source

Thanks to its continued popularity on mainstream retail sites, Morganite is readily available in calibrated cuts and sizes, making it an ideal choice for custom or made-to-order settings.

Top 5 Benefits of Morganite Engagement Rings

1. Soft, feminine hues that symbolise love

2. Lower price per carat than other pink stones

3. Looks especially striking in rose or yellow gold

4. Available in a range of cuts and sizes

5. Ideal for vintage, boho, and romantic styles

Fun fact: Morganite was named after American banker and gem enthusiast J.P. Morgan, one of the prominent gemstone patrons of the Gilded Age.

Cons and Considerations

What some buyers may overlook

Morganite's charm is clear—but so are its limits. While it offers a beautiful look and an attractive engagement ring cost, there are a few things every couple should know before committing.

It's not the hardest stone in the box

With a Mohs hardness between 7.5 and 8, Morganite is more susceptible to scratching than harder gems like sapphire (Mohs 9) or moissanite (9.25). Daily wear, especially in exposed settings, can lead to surface wear over time.

Toughness matters, too

Morganite belongs to the beryl family, like emerald and aquamarine. It has moderate toughness—meaning it's not especially brittle, but can still chip if knocked, particularly at sharp corners or exposed girdles. According to the International Gem Society, while Morganite has decent hardness, it's not especially tough. That means it may be susceptible to accidental damage, especially in high-set or unprotected rings.

Colour enhancements are common

Most Morganite on the market is heat-treated to intensify its pink tone, and in some cases, irradiation is used. While these treatments are stable, they should always be disclosed on certificates and valuations—especially for ring insurance purposes.

Soft brilliance, not high sparkle

With a refractive index between 1.57 and 1.60, Morganite offers a gentle glow rather than the fiery flash you'd see in diamonds or moissanite. This makes it better suited for romantic, low-light aesthetics than for those seeking maximum shine.

Visual Setting Tip

For everyday wear, consider protective styles like:

• Bezel settings (wrap the stone in metal for edge protection)

• Halo designs (add a buffer of smaller stones around the centre)

• Low-profile claws (keep the stone closer to the hand, reducing impact risk)

These settings can help offset the stone's vulnerabilities—while still showcasing its softness and warmth.

Morganite vs Other Pink Engagement Stones

How does it compare?

If you're considering a pink gemstone for your engagement ring, it's worth understanding how morganite measures up against other popular options like pink sapphire, lab-grown pink diamond and rose quartz. Each offers a different balance of durability, cost, and long-term wearability.

Morganite sits between 7.5 and 8 on the Mohs hardness scale. It's typically heat-treated (sometimes also irradiated) to enhance its soft blush colour, and has fair to good toughness. This makes it suitable for occasional wear, but it is more vulnerable to scratches and chips compared to harder gems. Prices typically range from $250 to $1,200 AUD, depending on size and saturation; however, resale potential is low—especially for treated stones without a premium origin or cut.

Pink sapphires offer a much tougher profile, with a Mohs hardness of 9 and excellent overall toughness. Most are heat-treated, but they hold their colour well, even with daily wear. Prices typically range between $1,800 and $5,000 AUD for a well-cut 1-carat stone, and resale value tends to be strong—particularly for unheated or origin-certified stones, such as Ceylon or Madagascar varieties.

Lab-grown pink diamonds top the chart in durability with a Mohs hardness of 10 and excellent toughness. These stones require no treatment and are created in lab environments with traceable supply chains. Cost ranges from $3,000 to $6,000 AUD per carat. While they don't hold their value like natural diamonds, they offer better resale than softer pink gems like Morganite or quartz.

Rose quartz, though visually appealing, is not ideal for engagement rings. With a hardness of only 7 and poor toughness, it's highly susceptible to scratches and fractures. It's rarely used in fine jewellery and typically priced between $80 and $250 AUD. Resale value is negligible.

Quick Takeaway: Morganite's soft glow and accessible price make it appealing, but it lags behind other pink gems in terms of strength and resale value. If long-term wearability is key, pink sapphire or lab-grown diamond may be better suited—especially if you're hoping to turn the ring into a family heirloom.

Caring for Morganite Jewellery

Tips to preserve its glow

Morganite may radiate a soft, romantic glow—but like all gemstones on the lower end of the hardness scale, it requires a little extra TLC. To keep it looking luminous for years to come, maintenance matters more than some people expect.

• Stick to warm water and mild soap: Harsh cleaners, ultrasonic machines and steamers can cause internal fractures or wear down surface polish. Use a soft toothbrush and pat dry with a lint-free cloth.

• Avoid sudden temperature changes and knocks: Beryl (the gem family Morganite belongs to) can be sensitive to thermal shock and impact. Remove rings during weight training, cleaning or gardening.

• Inspect your setting every 12 months: Because Morganite is softer than diamonds or sapphires, it's more likely to loosen in its setting over time—especially in high-set prongs. A quick annual jeweller check can prevent loss or damage.

• Expect to re-polish over time: Daily wear can cause the stone's surface to dull. A professional polish every few years can revive its glow without compromising the gem.

Pro tip: If your Morganite is mounted in a rose gold or mixed-metal setting, ask your jeweller whether the prongs need plating or reinforcement during your annual check.

For deeper tips on preserving your engagement ring, read: 15 Ways to Keep Your Engagement Ring Looking Brand New.

Insurance Considerations for Morganite Rings

Why the stone you choose affects your cover

Morganite's unique qualities—while beautiful—require a closer look when it comes to jewellery insurance. As a softer stone, it may present different risks and replacement challenges compared to harder gems, such as diamonds or sapphires.

• Durability affects long-term value: With a Mohs hardness of 7.5–8, Morganite may be more susceptible to scratching or chipping. Over time, that wear may impact valuations and potential claims if the ring is damaged or needs to be replaced.

• Treatments must be disclosed: Most Morganite is heat-treated (sometimes irradiated) to enhance its pink colour. Accurate documentation of these treatments is essential for fair appraisal and appropriate cover.

• Matching replacement stones can be tricky: Because colour, cut and saturation vary widely between morganite stones, sourcing a close match during a claim may not be straightforward. A detailed valuation, including photos, may help guide this process.

• Standard contents policies may fall short: Some home and contents policies have sub-limits or exclusions for things such as travel, wear, or custom gemstone replacement. These gaps may leave high-value or delicate stones underinsured.

Frequently Asked Questions About Morganite Engagement Rings

Are Morganites expensive?

Morganite is generally considered one of the more budget-friendly engagement ring stones. In 2025, most well-cut morganites range from A$250 to $1,200, depending on size, colour depth, and setting. That makes it significantly more accessible than pink sapphires or lab-grown pink diamonds, which often start at A$1,800+.

Keep in mind: rare, untreated Morganite in large carat sizes may sit at the higher end of the price spectrum.

Does Morganite scratch easily?

While Morganite is reasonably hard (7.5–8 on the Mohs scale), it's softer than diamonds, sapphires, or moissanite, which means it can scratch or show signs of wear over time—especially if worn daily.

Expert Tip: Opt for protective settings, such as bezels, halos, or low-profile claws, to help shield your stone.

How do you clean a Morganite ring?

To clean a morganite ring, use warm water, a soft toothbrush, and mild soap. Gently scrub around the claws and under the stone to remove oils and debris, then rinse and pat dry.

Avoid using ultrasonic and steam cleaners, as they can stress the stone or loosen claws over time.

How much should an engagement ring cost?

There's no set rule, but current averages in Australia range between A$5,000 and $7,500—with some couples choosing alternative stones like Morganite to allocate more of their budget toward custom settings or ethical sourcing. For more info check out our blog: How Much Should You Spend on an Engagement Ring in Australia?

How to insure an engagement ring?

To insure an engagement ring, you'll usually need:

• A recent valuation or purchase receipt

• Details of the stone type, treatments, and setting

• Images of the ring

You may want to consider looking for ring insurance that includes loss, theft, and damage, with features such as annual revaluation and the option to return to your original jeweller for repairs or replacements.

Are engagement rings covered on home insurance?

Some are, but cover may be limited or conditional. Some home contents policies may cap jewellery claims (e.g., $1,000–$2,500), exclude travel, or don't cover repairs or loss due to wear and tear.

For high-value or sentimental rings, you may wish to consider specialist jewellery insurance that includes more features and fewer exclusions.

How does engagement ring insurance work?

Engagement ring insurance works by providing financial cover in the event of your ring being lost, stolen, or damaged. Depending on the provider, you may receive:

• Repair or replacement options

• Worldwide coverage

• Flexibility to work with your chosen jeweller

• Annual revaluation to align with current market prices

Cover begins once documentation is approved and the ring is valued correctly or itemised.

A Glow Worth Knowing

Morganite may not headline 2025's engagement trends, but its warm, romantic tones still resonate with some couples who favour sentiment over sparkle. It offers beauty, affordability and meaning, but it deserves careful consideration. From durability and setting style to treatments and valuations, choosing Morganite means weighing both its charm and its challenges.

Whether your heart's set on blush-toned beryl or you're still exploring your options, don't overlook what happens after the ring is on the finger. Specialist engagement ring insurance can help ensure your chosen stone—whatever it may be—is covered for life's unexpected moments.

Looking to cover your engagement ring—whether it's diamond, sapphire or Morganite? Get an indicative quote from JewelCover today.